2 Applied Anthropology as Activist Practice in Southern Africa
Andrew Hartnack
Introduction
In early September 2012, I sat in a seminar room at the Anthropology Southern Africa annual conference at the University of Cape Town, where I was completing my PhD studies. Delegates bemoaned that in the raging public response to the infamous Marikana massacre two weeks previously,[1] anthropologists were seemingly voiceless. Despite a wealth of knowledge and insight on apartheid, capitalism, migrant labour and other relevant topics, anthropologists lagged behind public intellectuals from other disciplines in explaining this moment and articulating how South Africa could avoid such future disasters. Regardless of its rich history of exposé and activism against the apartheid state, the discipline was not agile enough to bring its significant and nuanced perspectives quickly into the debate in Op-Ed pieces or media interviews. Clearly there was a desire within anthropology to be relevant, visible and influential on significant contemporary issues, but it has not always been clear how anthropologists can achieve this.
The #Rhodesmustfall protests of 2015, which started at the same university and spawned an international student movement aimed at decolonising higher education, allowed anthropologists working in the region a chance to become more active and visible in public debates (see Nyamnjoh, 2016). The 2020-22 COVID-19 pandemic also offered this opportunity, yet among the myriad academic experts appearing in the media, I do not recall once seeing a medical anthropologist in print or on the television despite opportunities to explain, for example, the impacts that national lockdowns might have on various aspects of social and cultural life; or how certain beliefs about disease and medicine might impact government responses. While some may have been active on various social media platforms, their views were not influential. It took a year or two before ethnographic accounts exploring various aspects of COVID-19 started being published (e.g. Bank & Sharply, 2022).
There is clearly still some way to go to get anthropological insight quickly into the mainstream conversation. Indeed, some anthropologists in the region feel strongly that we should not be rushing to push perspectives into the public domain without first doing the conventional in-depth ethnographic work to understand the dynamics more fully. For example, during a presentation of an early draft of this chapter,[2] a senior anthropologist argued that during the COVID-19 pandemic, there were many academics making arguments on social and news media, based on very little actual evidence. He argued for the importance of anthropology in offering carefully distilled knowledge based on long-term fieldwork. I understand this reluctance, yet in this chapter I contend that there are many anthropologists working outside academia on issues related to the most pressing contemporary social justice and developmental challenges, whose perspectives could assist the discipline to showcase its engagement more clearly. Perspectives from such applied anthropologists have largely been sidelined, constituting a lost opportunity for anthropology in its quest to be both agile and relevant to the most pressing problems facing the region. I will argue, using my own 20-year career as an applied anthropologist, that applied anthropology can be valuable to the discipline in southern Africa; specifically in producing grounded insights about human and economic development questions, and in its ability to produce insights quickly and in formats more suitable for non-academic audiences, including policymakers.
Historical Misgivings
Anthropology in southern Africa has always sought to be relevant and engaged, even if its perspectives have not been central in public debates. The region’s colonial and apartheid history provided a complex context which shaped the practice of anthropology. In South Africa, where most universities and the largest pool of anthropologists were based, a British-influenced structural functionalist school of social anthropology emerged at English-medium universities in the first half of the 20th century. Meanwhile, at Afrikaans-medium universities following a German ethnology paradigm, a school that came to be known as Volkekunde (literally the study of ‘folk’) developed (see van der Waal, 2015). Volkekunde became heavily involved in the apartheid project in the second half of the 20th century, with Volkekunde anthropologists working directly for the apartheid state in its various racist projects. Indeed, by the 1970s the single largest employer of anthropologists and ethnologists was the South African Defence Force (Gordon, 2010).[3]
While the Volkekunde anthropologists engaged in this dubious form of applied anthropology, social anthropologists increasingly came to see their role as speaking truth to power, challenging the apartheid state in various ways through their work. At some universities, a radical Marxist political economy paradigm also emerged, with anthropologists seeking to expose the effects of apartheid’s separate development policy, the Group Areas Act, forced removals, migrant labour, capitalist exploitation, social disintegration and so on (Sharp, 1994; Sharp & Spiegel, 1985). These anthropologists were already applying their anthropology in the fight against apartheid, some like Johnny Clegg in creative realms such as music. While other disciplines also proved active in these endeavours, social anthropologists were by no means silent.
After the fall of apartheid, many of the former political economy and social anthropologists sought to turn their attention to understanding the cultural and socio-economic complexities and needs of the new South Africa. Some argued that anthropologists needed to move beyond the ethics of exposé, towards an ethics of care (Spiegel, 2005). This was an engaged anthropology and it was made even more so by the #Rhodesmustfall protests of 2015 and the subsequent debates around decolonising academia. Volkekunde, meanwhile, dissolved, and former Volkekunde anthropologists either retired or renounced their previous position (see van der Waal, 2015); others reinvented themselves as applied anthropologists, working for entities involved in various development endeavours, such as land reform, tourism, mining or agriculture.[4] Due to this history, and a pre-existing disciplinary ambivalence towards applied anthropology (see Sillitoe, 2007), the post-apartheid anthropological mainstream has not embraced applied anthropology to the extent that anthropology elsewhere seemingly has. In particular, there is a suspicion towards those applying anthropology in service of various extractive and capitalist endeavours, rather than on social justice issues. I argue, however, that it is time for anthropology to more directly embrace and promote the work of the many applied anthropologists in the arena of social justice. Most of these are graduates of local anthropology departments who have chosen, or been forced to, apply their skills outside of academia, addressing the most pressing challenges of the day. Embracing these perspectives is important given the myriad political, economic and developmental challenges facing the region, and the discipline’s desire to be at the forefront of solutions.
Pathways into Applied Anthropology
My anthropology journey commenced in 1998, when I registered for a degree at Rhodes University in South Africa’s Eastern Cape province. It was always my intention to apply my anthropological training after graduation in rural development or livelihood enhancement in my home country, Zimbabwe. My training at Rhodes was fairly practical, with modules in such areas as refugee studies; the anthropology of work and leisure; medical and environmental anthropology; political and economic anthropology. I started my working career at a Zimbabwean environmental non-profit organisation in 2002 before returning in 2004 to Rhodes University for a Masters degree. My research examined the impacts of displacement on Zimbabwean farm workers following Robert Mugabe’s controversial land reforms. Upon completion of this degree I moved to Cape Town.
When finding a full-time job at an academic research institute or development organisation proved difficult, I opted to look for work as an independent research consultant in the development field. I initially considered seeking work with consultancy firms conducting the environmental and social impact assessments (EIAs/SIAs) that large development projects are legally required to complete before commencement. This is one area where applied anthropologists have been employed, and I did conduct a few social assessments of low-cost housing and roads projects. Although I recognise the argument that anthropologists should become involved in these development processes to ensure the best possible outcomes for affected people and communities, I soon decided that I would avoid getting involved with SIAs, particularly of extractive projects such as mining or large-scale agriculture. I also did not pursue work in resettlement action planning for communities being displaced as a result of planned developments (e.g. dams), despite a displacement studies background. There is much of this work available in Africa, but I was not comfortable being part of what I came to see as a rubber-stamping process in which big developers always seemed to win. My personal choice here was influenced by personal interest in environmental issues, as well as ethical concerns about the power relations in the development process. For me, it is important for applied anthropologists to carefully consider such power relations and whether those with limited power can realistically benefit from big development projects.
Instead, I became involved in the research, monitoring and evaluation of social development projects largely implemented by South African and international NGOs. Most of my work as an independent researcher and evaluator has been in such fields as migration, public health, education, early childhood development (ECD), livelihoods, environment and youth empowerment. I have always positioned myself as a qualitative evaluator and researcher, able to apply my research expertise to a range of social and developmental issues. In 2012, to enhance my knowledge, skills and marketability I undertook a PhD in which I explored welfare, land reform and labour dynamics in Zimbabwe’s commercial farming sector. I’ve been able to use this knowledge, along with perspectives from medical anthropology, the anthropology of the state, economic and developmental anthropology, and the anthropology of childhood in my consultancy work. Anthropologists whose work and theoretical perspectives I have found particularly valuable include James Ferguson, James Scott, Donald Moore, Fiona Ross, Ann Laura Stoler, Tania Li and Vinh-Kim Nguyen. I’ve found that having these anthropological perspectives and theoretical tools allows me to offer a unique and valuable contribution.
The reason this kind of work has become so important, and why I think there is a critical role for applied anthropology in South(ern) Africa, is because in these sectors in which I am involved, there is a clear and growing crisis. This socio-economic, political and increasingly environmental crisis has been brought about by the gradual erosion of the public health, education and social welfare systems, and rising levels of poverty, inequality and youth unemployment in the region. The adoption of neoliberal macro-economic policies, along with corruption, and the capture of state institutions by corrupt elites (see Bond and Malikane, 2019) has meant that the state has retreated from its former strong role in social development, while basic service delivery has deteriorated, if not collapsed.
Concurrently, socio-economic indicators continue to worsen, and climate change is increasingly impacting local ways of life in the form of intensifying droughts, floods and fires. The role of civil society organisations in filling the gap left behind by the retreating or failing state, and addressing these problems, is crucial to prevent the almost total collapse of sectors such as health and education, and to address social issues such as malnutrition and child stunting, communicable disease vulnerability, school dropout, lack of employment and livelihood opportunities, and forms of gender-based and other violence which pervade society. The current socio-economic conditions, combined with the persisting structural inequalities and spatial apartheid has been characterised as “slow violence” by scholars (e.g. Nixon, 2011). This calls for an activist anthropology operating in both the academy and in applied settings like NGOs; which uses both research and advocacy to drive systemic changes for the better in the critical areas where the structural (or “slow”) violence is pervasive.
While academic colleagues like Morreira (2012) have made similar calls, applied anthropologists working outside of academia, on the front lines of these issues, are in a particularly important position to combine research and practice in ways which can quickly become influential and make a difference. Unlike traditional anthropological insight, which is often based on long-term fieldwork and relies on the slow academic publishing process, applied anthropology’s insights can be more practical and suitable for rapid dissemination and advocacy. Globally, more and more anthropology graduates are finding themselves working in applied settings, where they can have this kind of impact (see Field & Fox, 2007).
Applying an Anthropological Toolkit
Anthropology has given me an invaluable perspective on humans and human development which I bring into my applied work. Much as I am trained and market myself as a social scientist, I regard anthropology as a human-centred enquiry and a form of story-telling aimed at bringing about positive socio-economic and systemic change. Curiosity about people and the social, cultural, spatial, environmental and economic dynamics in which they are entangled drives this enquiry process. At the same time, I am able to use my understanding of the complex and dynamic cultural and historical context of southern Africa to inform my applied work. My work involves building rapport with development project implementers, partners and beneficiaries over time, a skill I learnt from anthropology. My multi-sited, mobile ethnography experience honed in academic work has been crucial as I am often under time pressure in applied work, needing to build rapport quickly and shift between different spaces, contexts and people to get rich data in constrained conditions. I use what Trotter, Schensul & Kostik (2014, p. 681) refer to as “rapid ethnographic assessment”. I also often find myself in dangerous places, such as peri-urban slums, which calls on my experience of conducting similar work during academic studies.
Rather than using an extractive process based on rigid and pre-determined check-boxes or survey questions, I use a conversational and ethnographic form of dialogue to explore contextual dynamics, project models, implementation and outcomes. I use participant observation as a key tool, and I also use participatory methods where possible, such as photovoice, art workshops and journaling – especially with young research participants.[5] I am able to look for nuance as a result of my anthropological training; I have an understanding of and sensitivity to power relations in the development process; and I also understand agency, resistance and resilience among the intended targets of assistance (things which project implementers sometimes fail to take into account). My postgraduate research helped me gain key insights into the dynamics of welfarism, NGOs, civil society and the state, and I understand the political economy of development. All of these foundations have stood me in good stead as an evaluator, enabling me to go beyond simply measuring indicators, identifying challenges or quantifying success. Through the process of research and evaluation I find that I often help implementers to better understand the value of what they do and how they do it, as well as the context in which they are working. I have also enabled some to think more critically about their work and the systemic impact they can make. I find that a key role I play is linking people to others who are doing synergistic work in different parts of the region, sharing contacts and ideas which assist to strengthen the work.
At times I am asked specifically to conduct ethnographic work to inform campaigns or policies. The International Organisation for Migration, for example, commissioned me to undertake country studies in 2009, to feed into the regional migrant health policy of a major funder. More recently, I conducted an ethnographic enquiry into the causes of littering and dumping of solid waste in Gauteng province, South Africa. The rich insights on the systemic, structural and behavioural drivers of littering and dumping – gained through my ethnographic and participatory approach, as well as anthropological theory[6] – informed a high profile campaign seeking to contribute to systemic change in this area.[7] I have since shared this research with influential officials in the City of Bulawayo (Zimbabwe) and Cape Town. I am also increasingly working in the early childhood development (ECD) sector, conducting research on issues such as child nutrition and how the government can better support the sector through, for example, adopting an enabling set of norms and standards and implementing a programmatic approach to ECD provision. This research, also informed by my involvement in relief implementation for ECD during the COVID-19 pandemic,[8] is contributing to concerted lobbying of the government to get them to invest more in supporting ECD as a crucial development priority. This ECD work is a good example of an area where applied anthropology practice and research can be used in an agile manner to directly influence government policy and practice much more quickly than pure academic work can.
Another area in which research and evaluation I have done is being used to make a systemic change is on the issue of school dropout – a major challenge in South Africa where over 40% of children who start school fail to reach their final year.[9] A research paper on the drivers of school dropout was influential in informing a nationwide campaign led by a philanthropic organisation, in which dropout reduction models implemented by NGOs were incubated and lessons then fed into the policy conversation. My role was the in-depth documentation of these dropout prevention models to inform the campaign and its policy demands. I also specifically conducted ethnographic research on a rural school district to illustrate the causes of dropout in a poor rural context.[10] The background paper I wrote (Hartnack, 2017) has also proved influential beyond this campaign, being cited in local and international literature over 50 times (to date) since it was published. It has been used mostly by academic researchers, indicating that commissioned research and policy papers can also be of great value, even if they are not accorded the same status as academic literature.
Maintaining Academic Citizenship
Despite working independently outside of academia, I have found it important to maintain my academic connections and citizenship – not least because of the legitimacy this accords my work, and also to retain access to some academic resources and opportunities. I have done this through cultivating research associateships with anthropology departments at South African institutions; giving or attending seminars; occasional lecturing; publishing and peer reviewing journal articles and book manuscripts; reviewing books; examining theses; and supervising a PhD candidate. I have found it more difficult to attend conferences due to time and funding constraints. Many funding streams available to tenured academic colleagues are closed to those of us working independently and, despite associating with academic departments, I have struggled to obtain library access, which makes accessing many journal articles and books difficult as they are protected by paywalls.
I have also found it challenging to publish applied anthropological knowledge in academic journals, or academic platforms. At times research carried out in an applied manner, as part of a developmental process, is not accepted by academic reviewers who expect a more rigid or conventional research process to have been followed. This has been a particular challenge when reviewers are from disciplines such as public health, which have very specific expectations about how qualitative research is conducted. This means that lessons and insights arising from development praxis may never make it into mainstream academic debates. Publishing such insights on platforms like The Conversation has also been difficult, as they tend to only accept the work of those employed full-time in an academic institution.
Working in applied anthropology therefore sometimes feels a little like being on the margins of the discipline. Despite the important role applied anthropologists play, there still seems to be a general arms-length ambivalence towards those who ply their trade outside of academia. Nevertheless, it is important for applied anthropologists to maintain strong links with their colleagues inside academia and for knowledge to be shared both ways, for the betterment of the discipline (Sillitoe, 2007, p. 161). Things are starting to shift in this regard: in 2025 I was invited to become one of the editors of the Anthropology Southern Africa association’s journal, a sign that those working outside the academy are being noticed and our work respected.
Conclusion
In this chapter, I have argued that in southern Africa, a social justice-focussed applied anthropology is necessary, given the complex socio-economic, political and environmental challenges faced in the region. The regional history of anthropology has ensured that applied anthropology has often been overlooked as a core arm of the discipline in the era of democracy. Applied anthropologists have not been invited into the mainstream of the discipline, despite their growing role in producing grounded insights on key issues. As anthropology seeks to ensure that it can bring its considerable insight and uniquely important perspectives to bear on important issues, applied anthropology should become a valuable asset in producing quick and relevant views for the public and policy-makers. It can also be involved in many aspects of humanitarian and developmental practice which not only test and incubate innovative solutions, but also produce “real-time” knowledge which can be shared in more accessible formats than the usual academic publishing process allows. Of course, applied anthropologists should also be aware of the ethics and power relations of working in particular aspects of development, and indeed, they also have a large role to play in critiquing development or policy which perpetuates structural inequalities and systemic problems.
The discipline in southern Africa can be richer, more effective and visible, with an ongoing and productive engagement between more traditional academic modes of practicing anthropology, and those who have adopted a more practical and applied form of anthropology. A good next step in creating this collaboration would be a panel on applied anthropology at the Anthropology Southern Africa association’s annual conference, as well as a special issue on applied anthropology in the association’s journal. Universities should also consider granting library access to anthropologists working outside the academy, and applied anthropologists should also be invited as visiting scholars by anthropology departments to feed their insights more directly into the curriculum.
References
du Preez, A. (2015). The Marikana massacre: Seeing it all. Safundi, 16(4), 419-442. https://doi.org/10.1080/17533171.2015.1116831
Bank, L. & Sharpley, N. (2022). COVID and custom in rural South Africa: Culture, healthcare and the state. Hurst.
Becker, H., Boonzaier, E., & Owen, J. (2005). Fieldwork in shared spaces: Positionality, power and ethics of citizen anthropologists in southern Africa. Anthropology Southern Africa, 28(3-4), 123-132. https://doi.org/10.1080/23323256.2005.11499922
Bond, P., & Malikane, C. (2019). Inequality caused by macro-economic policies during overaccumulation crisis. Development Southern Africa, 36(6), 803-820, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0376835X.2019.1701416
Cheater, A. P. (1987). The anthropologist as citizen: The diffracted self? In A. Jackson (Ed.). Anthropology at home. Tavistock Publications.
Douglas, M., (2003). Purity and danger: An analysis of concepts of pollution and taboo. Routledge.
Ferguson, J. (1999). Expectations of modernity: Myths and Meanings of Urban Life on the Zambian Copperbelt. University of California Press.
Field, L. W., & Fox, R. G. (2007). Anthropology put to Work. Berg.
Gordon, R. (2010, February 22). Anthropology and apartheid: The rise of military ethnology in South Africa. Cultural Survival Quarterly. https://www.culturalsurvival.org/publications/cultural-survival-quarterly/anthropology-and-apartheid-rise-military-ethnology-south
Hartnack, A. (2009). An exposé ethnography of Zimbabwe’s internally displaced ex-farm workers: Practical and ethical dilemmas. Anthropology Southern Africa, 32(3&4), 117-127.
Hartnack, A. (2016). Ordered estates: Welfare, power and maternalism on Zimbabwe’s (once white) Highveld. Weaver Press.
Hartnack, A. (2017). Background document and review of key South African and international literature on school dropout. DG Murray Trust.
Marcus, G. (1995). Ethnography in/of the world system: the emergence of multi-sited ethnography. Annual Review of Anthropology, 24, 95-117.
Moore, D. (2005). Suffering for territory: Race, place and power in Zimbabwe. Duke University Press.
Morreira, S. (2012). ‘Anthropological futures’? Thoughts on social research and the ethics of engagement. Anthropology Southern Africa, 35(3–4), 100–104. https://doi.org/10.1080/23323256.2012.11500029
Nixon, R., (2011). Slow violence and the environmentalism of the poor. Harvard University Press.
Nyamnjoh, F. B. (2016). #RhodesMustFall: Nibbling at resilient colonialism in South Africa. Langaa RPCIG, 2016. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvmd84n8.1.
Rutherford, B. (2000). Working on the margins: Black workers, white farmers in postcolonial Zimbabwe. Weaver Press
Sharp, J. (1994). A world turned upside down: Households and differentiation in a South African Bantustan in the 1980s. African Studies, 53(1).
Sharp, J., & Spiegel, A. (1985). Vulnerability to impoverishment in South African rural areas: The erosion of kinship and neighbourhood as social resources. Africa, 55(2).
Spiegel, A. (2005). From exposé to care: Preliminary thoughts about shifting the ethical concerns of South African social anthropology. Anthropology Southern Africa, 28(3-4), 133-141. https://doi.org/10.1080/23323256.2005.11499923
Sillitoe, P. (2007). Anthropologists only need apply: challenges of applied anthropology. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 13(1), 147-165.
Stoler, A. L. (2010). Carnal knowledge and imperial power: Race and the intimate in colonial rule. University of California Press.
Trotter, R. T., Schensul, J. J., & Kostik, K. M. (2014). Theories and methods in applied anthropology. In H. Russell Bernard and C. C. Gravlee (Eds). Handbook of methods in cultural anthropology. Rowman & Littlefield.
Van der Waal, C. S. (2015). Long walk from Volkekunde to anthropology: reflections on representing the human in South Africa. Anthropology Southern Africa, 38(3&4), 216-234.
- The Marikana massacre is an event in mid-August 2012 where 34 striking miners in South Africa’s North West province were shot dead by members of the South African Police Service (see du Preez, 2015, among others). ↵
- Seminar in the Anthropology and Development Studies Department at the University of Johannesburg (5 March 2025). ↵
- It must be noted that not all Afrikaans-speaking anthropologists joined the Volkekunde school – some notable scholars opposed the apartheid state. ↵
- I obtained this impression from attending Anthropology Southern Africa association conferences in the late 1990s, where these former Volkekunde anthropologists often presented papers on their applied work. They were looked on with suspicion by other conference attendees. ↵
- These are tools commonly used in participatory action research, in which research participants themselves drive the knowledge generation process. ↵
- In this instance, perspectives on liminality, purity and pollution, as raised by Douglas (2003). ↵
- See Create Change Around South Africa’s Waste Problem ↵
- See Covid children’s project teaches crucial lessons ↵
- See New National Survey Reveals SA’s Experiences of Education and Dropout / ↵
- See Zero Dropout ↵