8 Transformative Ethnographies: Anthropological Methods for Context-Based Solutions
Cecilia Iaconelli
Field: Strategic Urban Regeneration/Planning/Design
Applied anthropology is simply “anthropology put to use” (van Willigen, 1980/2002). It is any kind of anthropological research that is done to solve practical problems. This definition, as I show in this chapter, defines my fieldwork experiences in Belmonte Calabro and Milano Martesana Park, exploring the potential contribution of anthropology to the design of public spaces. These two different places represent challenges I have addressed through anthropological methods. Throughout this journey, we’ll explore the transformative potential of anthropology, starting from its fundamental paradigm: considering the world as something socially constructed. By recognising our spaces as socially constructed (Geertz, 1973; Ingold, 2000; Lefebvre, 1974; Low, 2009; M. Santos, 1979), we understand that they do not simply exist, but are rather actively created through our interaction with them. It follows that just as something was made, it can be remade or recreated differently. From this perspective, creation does not follow a single prescribed method; instead, it opens up to numerous possibilities that emerge through diverse ways of knowing and interacting with space. This relational approach resonates with an intersubjective understanding of space, where meaning and form are co-produced through ongoing social and cultural interactions.
I will explore how anthropological observation methods can help us detect these social constructions through the use of what I call a “nonjudgmental gaze”. That is, an observation-driven approach which allows for the formulation of solutions grounded in real-life contexts, moving beyond imposed judgments and attending to local particularities. Here I offer two examples in the hope they can inspire new perspectives and spark fresh ideas for creating more inclusive, sustainable, and vibrant public spaces.

Benches of a semi-abandoned village in Calabria
Belmonte Calabro is a semi-abandoned village located in Calabria, a region in southern Italy. As in many other parts of Italy, the village has experienced a gradual decline due to an ageing population, migration and economic changes. As a result, there are few inhabitants left and several areas of the village have been abandoned.
To combat this decline, a cultural association of young international architects and designers was founded in 2017. The project aimed to use the tools of design and architecture to strengthen the sense of community, promote social integration and encourage territorial development.
From 2017 to 2021, the association organised various activities. These included the construction of decorative architectural elements such as garlands, small theatres and wooden structures to enliven the main square; the organisation of an annual meeting with architects and students from various European universities; and the opening of a permanent building as the cultural centre’s headquarters to promote co-design sessions, idea exchanges and activities with the local population.
However, the permanent cultural centre had low attendance from the local community. The artistic artefacts, built during pop-up workshops and the annual meeting, were stored in warehouses and not used beyond the individual events in which they were created. In order to guarantee the long-term sustainability of the activities conducted in Belmonte Calabro, there was a clear need to develop strategies for establishing a continuous and significant relationship with the local community. In spring 2021, the cultural association approached me to conduct a month-long ethnographic research to investigate these aspects.
At the time, the village was experiencing an outbreak of COVID-19, and strict rules were in place to contain the local population and limit human-to-human contact. The research therefore had to adapt creatively to these limitations, using ad hoc methods to gain a comprehensive insight into the cultural landscape of Belmonte Calabro. I began by exploring the village and analysing the context through the lens of “traces”,[1] observing objects and reminiscences[2] in public spaces, acting as an archaeologist of the present-day to decipher the ongoing dynamics within the community.
Various elements in public spaces were photographed, geo-tagged and coded to create aggregated maps (see Figure 2 and Figure 3), thereby making knowledge visible. Employing geo-referenced criteria for cartographic spatial depiction provided several advantages. By mapping out spatial data in a geo-tagged format, researchers could visually represent geographical patterns and distributions of cultural elements. This approach facilitated a deeper understanding of spatial relationships and highlighted significant cultural features within the community.
The data coding process and maps revealed key elements, which were then further enriched through semi-structured telephone interviews and informal street conversations, providing deeper insights into the cultural significance of these elements.


The findings revealed that the participation of local residents in activities organised by the cultural association was significantly limited due to a perceived cultural gap between them and the locals. Aesthetic perceptions played a key role in highlighting cultural nuances that heavily influenced the situation. For example, the cultural association building’s design features unrefined walls and exposed electrical conduits (see Figure 4 and Figure 5). The artisanal furniture, including chairs, tables, and sofas, has a modern aesthetic with nods to Nordic designers (see Figure 4, Figure 5, Figure 6). This stark contrast with local aesthetic values caused discomfort and a sense of disorientation among local people when entering the space.





In addition, I identified several symbolic elements linked to local cultural values that could serve as focal points of the efforts of the cultural association to create different solutions. One example was in the culture of gardening and horticulture, evident in the multitude of plant pots that adorn the front of nearly every house (see Figure 9 and Figure 10). Several of my informants took me enthusiastically to their gardens, proudly showing me their plants (see Figure 11 and Figure 12). These observations suggest that an initiative, like the creation of a communal garden space where resident’s plant cuttings are symbolically extended into a communal garden, might foster a sense of collective ownership and community engagement while actively valuing local participation.





Moreover, ethnographic observation and the geo-tagging revealed an intriguing finding: the number of benches and private chairs in public spaces exceeded the number of passers-by (see Figure 14, Figure 15, and Figure 16). While seemingly irrational, this phenomenon highlights the importance of public seating for the local population.
Two key cultural values emerged during interviews with residents.
The first is the deep connection between local identity and the contemplation of the surrounding landscape. Residents often describe their sense of self in relation to the places they inhabit. This connection is so profound that even in Belmonte Calabro’s cemetery, many tombstones feature photographs of the deceased with the village’s iconic view as a backdrop.
The second cultural value lies in the extension of private objects into public spaces. Residents commonly place their personal chairs in the narrow alleys of the village. These chairs serve as powerful social connectors, transforming streets into communal spaces where private life spills over into public areas. They foster a sense of community and conviviality, creating spaces for conversation, for the exchange of local news, and for sharing moments of leisure.
In this context, seating in Belmonte takes on a rich symbolic significance. It reflects the identitarian value placed on pausing to enjoy the shared landscape and highlights the social cohesion sustained through close interpersonal interactions.
During fieldwork, I had the opportunity to map these chairs and benches. Although they were temporarily empty due to a COVID-19 outbreak, the chairs remained an important marker of community life. Residents continued to keep their chairs outside, even during the lockdown, as silent witnesses to a vital aspect of their social and cultural identity.
By using anthropological tools, I analysed existing activities and identified previously overlooked elements, such as the surplus of benches. These benches have the potential to serve as powerful cultural symbols that can ignite community-led design initiatives. This approach begins with empirical observation and emphasises contextual factors, distinguishing it from traditional case study methods conventionally employed by designers. Rather than imposing universal solutions from somewhere else, it encourages the development of solutions that are deeply rooted in local dynamics.
As a final result, all these elements and cultural values were shared in different ways: through a meeting with the clients and a final presentation involving both the local community and the clients themselves. The first meeting consisted of a presentation in which the main cultural values were illustrated, along with concrete examples. This helped to guide the selection and planning of further in-depth studies aimed at developing a territorial project that placed these values at its core.
The final phase of the project involved a participatory meeting with the local population, during which deeply symbolic themes emerged, sparking animated discussions with a strong emotional impact. For the first time, the inhabitants had the opportunity to openly discuss the dynamics related to their collective sense-making. In particular, this meeting marked the beginning of an initial process of reinterpreting the impact of ongoing migration phenomena in the semi-abandoned village.
Unlike other disciplines, anthropology places great emphasis on sharing findings with participants in a way that invites reflection and dialogue; turning those studied into active participants in the process. Such moments go beyond simply reading a report; they can become a cathartic intervention, laying the groundwork for a shared analysis of meanings and fostering a deeper collective elaboration of communal understanding and transformation.
It is important to highlight that in anthropological research, the boundary between data collection and data sharing is often blurred, a dialogical and co-constructed process in which knowledge emerges through ongoing interaction between researchers and participants (Clifford & Marcus, 1986; Lassiter, 2005; Pink, 2009). Even during the data collection phase, informants actively contribute by discussing cultural codes and values, generating an ongoing dialogue and often engaging in transformative self-analysis. Through this process, they may recognize, challenge, or redefine the interpretations being formed, fostering an ongoing process of re-signification and the co-creation of collective meaning.
A particularly significant example is the coding posters I voluntarily displayed inside the cultural center (see Figure 2). These attracted great interest from local visitors, who frequently stopped to comment on the visual material and engaged in conversations that provided me with ever-deeper insights.






The Martesana Multicultural Park
Parco della Martesana is an urban park in Milan, located in the heart of the multicultural Loreto district. The park is the only open public space in the neighbourhood and holds significance as an important symbolic space that represents the area’s cultural diversity. Because of its characteristics, I was interested in embarking on an exploratory study using ethnographic methods. The aim of this project was to develop proposals for cultural associations operating in the park that would be of local social benefit. Unlike my previous research, which was commissioned by an organization to address a specific territorial issue, this study functioned as a pilot initiative. Its purpose was to provide local associations with an initial overview of the context, which could later support funding applications to carry out concrete actions within the park.
Participant observation was central to the research approach. More than a technique, it entails immersing oneself in the community, engaging with people in their everyday environments, and attending to how practices and interactions emerge in situ rather than through preconceived expectations. The method involved taking detailed notes on behaviours, interactions, and spatial practices, while dialogue with community members offered insight into the perspectives through which these practices gained meaning.
This observation sought to be as descriptive as possible (linking back to the ‘non-judgemental gaze’ mentioned in the introduction), avoiding imposed judgements or preconceived notions in relation to the data collected. Observations were carried out on a fortnightly basis from December 2021 to April 2022, and drew on grounded theory to guide the iterative process of data collection and analysis .
Grounded theory, developed by Corbin and Strauss (1990), is a method for investigating social and cultural processes through the iterative collection and coding of qualitative data. The researcher cycles between fieldwork and analysis: gathering observations, interviews, sound recordings, documents, and photographs; coding them to identify emerging patterns; then returning to the field to refine or challenge these categories. Its distinctiveness lies in this recursive movement between data and analysis, where theoretical insight is generated inductively rather than imposed in advance.

During this phase, I noticed a striking incongruity: while the park initially appeared to be a melting pot of different cultural backgrounds, closer observation revealed limited interaction between people from distinct groups. This led to a segmentation of the community into social bounded clusters that were physically visible within the space (see Figure 21 and Figure 22). Such fragmentation hinders intercultural exchange within the public space, reducing multiculturalism to a superficial label and stifling potential for more enriching encounters.


The set of methods, outlined at the beginning of this section, not only helped me identify this issue but also revealed opportunities to promote social interactions.
Participant observation highlighted specific areas where occasional encounters already occurred.
For example, interactions were more likely to occur in the children’s playground area (Figure 26), mainly between children rather than adults, and in different types of queues such as those for public toilets, ice cream cargo bikes and drinking fountains (see Figure 23, Figure 24 and Figure 25). These observations underscore the potential of anthropological thinking to promote community cohesion by activating semi-dormant touchpoints and strengthening existing spaces




Conclusion
In this reflection, we have gathered a series of understandings on how to approach spatial issues to identify both the challenges and potentials of an area, transforming them into opportunities for developing effective solutions. Anthropological thinking provides highly valid and flexible methods for capturing local cultural dynamics, thereby revealing unique perspectives and viewpoints.
To conclude, this contribution highlights the distinctive ways anthropological thinking can address spatial challenges and possibilities:
- Anthropological methods prioritise solutions-based approaches over imposing external designs by exploring existing cultural elements. This observation-driven approach allows for the formulation of solutions grounded in real-life contexts, moving beyond imposed judgments and attending to local particularities. Thus, physical immersion in specific contexts enables the creation of effective solutions rooted in empirical elements rather than relying on the application of case studies.
- Anthropological thinking pursues a ‘nonjudgmental’ gaze facilitating a deeper understanding of our surroundings. By actively deconstructing assumptions that limit our comprehension of diverse communities, anthropology encourages an open-minded and empathetic approach in urban interventions. Central to this process are the concepts of reflexivity and positionality, which invite researchers to critically reflect on their own social positions, biases, and influence within the research. Engaging with reflexivity and positionality helps ensure that knowledge production is not one-sided but rather acknowledges the complex interplay between the observer and the observed, fostering more ethical and nuanced urban interventions.
- Anthropology’s socio-constructivist perspective acknowledges the fluidity of reality and the role of collective creation. It emphasises the ever-evolving nature of reality and the collaborative role in its creation, fostering more comprehensive and community- driven urban interventions.
- Anthropological research and thinking are distinguished by their deeply transformative nature, even in the process of data sharing. This goes beyond presenting findings; it actively involves study participants in the co-construction of data and meaning that concerns them. In so doing, data sharing itself becomes a moment of participation and transformation, offering individuals the opportunity to deepen their awareness of themselves and others. Through this ongoing dialogue, people can recognize, redefine, or question their own perceptions, fostering a more dynamic and shared understanding of their surroundings.
References
Clifford, J. & Marcus, G. E. (Eds.). (1986). Writing culture: The poetics and politics of ethnography. University of California Press.
Corbin, J., & Strauss, A. L. (1990). Grounded theory research: Procedures, canons, and evaluative criteria. Qualitative Sociology, 13(1), 3–21. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00988593
Geertz, C. (1973). The interpretation of cultures: Selected essays. Basic Books.
Ingold, T. (2000). The perception of the environment: Essays on livelihood, dwelling and skill. Routledge.
Lassiter, L. E. (2005). The Chicago guide to collaborative ethnography. University of Chicago Press.
Lefebvre, H. (1974). The production of space. Blackwell Publishers.
Low, S. M. (2009). Towards an anthropological theory of space and place. Seminar.net – International Journal of Media, Technology and Lifelong Learning, 5(2), 1–10.
Masters, E. L. (1992). Spoon River anthology. Courier Corporation.
Pink, S. (2009). Doing sensory ethnography. SAGE Publications.
Santos, B. de S. (2011). Epistemologia del sur. Revista Internacional de Filosofía Iberoamericana y Teoría Social, 16(54), 17–39.
Santos, M. (1996). A natureza do espaço: Técnica e tempo, razão e emoção. Hucitec.
Soja, E. (1996). Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and other real-and imagined places. Blackwell.
Teti, V. (2004). Il senso dei luoghi: Memoria e storia dei paesi abbandonati. Donzelli Editore.
van Willigen, J. (2002). Applied anthropology: An introduction, (3rd ed.). Bergin & Garvey.
Photos included in this chapter were taken during the author’s research and verbal consent was obtained at this time. If there any concerns about the photos used, visit Photography for more information.
- I was inspired by the descriptions provided by Vito Teti, an anthropologist hailing from the same region as Belmonte Calabro, who has devoted much of his scholarly work to abandoned villages. In his writing, Teti (2004) discusses how we construct meaning from abandoned spaces by analysing the traces and artefacts that bear testimony to the recent past. ↵
- The first location observed was the cemetery of Belmonte Calabro, chosen due to its resonance with the themes explored in the Spoon River Anthology (Masters, 1914/1992).The literary work reveals the relationships and social dynamics within an imaginary American village through its epitaphs. Similarly, exploring Belmonte Calabro's cemetery offers insights into the interconnectedness and narratives of its inhabitants. This choice was pivotal in developing an experimental methodology within a semi-abandoned village, as it underscored the significance of reminiscences in augmenting collective memory. Cemeteries, as repositories of past lives and narratives, serve as poignant reflections of societal changes and community identity, thus enriching our understanding of heritage and cultural dynamics. ↵